Smelly Markers: Scented Washable Ink, and Where It Goes

A smelly marker is a washable marker with fragrance added to the ink, so every surface verdict it carries is a washable verdict and the scent changes none of them. That means paper, glass, ceramic, skin and car glass, and only a conditional pass on fabric. Smelly markers draws 1,200 searches a month at keyword difficulty 0.

Smelly markers are scented washable markers, and that sentence answers most of what people want to know. The fragrance sits in water-soluble dye, so the pen behaves exactly like any other washable marker on every surface. See what buyers report about scented markers for the range; this page is about the ink and the smell.

Smelly markers carries 1,200 searches a month at keyword difficulty 0 and was flat year on year at minus 0.8%. Scented markers, the more formal phrasing, carries 1,900 and mr sketch scented markers 1,700. Smelling markers adds 200, smell markers 150 and scented markers 90s another 200, which tells you something about who is searching. Across 163 keywords the family totals 9,800 searches a month.

The surface verdicts are washable verdicts

Five clean works cells: paper at 40 searches a month, glass at 1,480, ceramic, skin at 750 and car windows at 500. Fabric is conditional at 1,360 and the cell is honest about why, washing out of most cotton but not out of everything. Whiteboard is conditional at 500, metal at 260, plastic at 80 and cardboard at 410. Chalkboard, wood and stone all fail, because porous surfaces hold dye and will not give it back.

Nothing in that row moves because a marker smells of grape. If a scented pen is going anywhere other than paper, check the cell first.

What to buy

The catalogue holds 96 washable markers at a median price of $14.54 and a median rating of 4.7, the highest median rating of the eleven types here.

Mr. Sketch Scented Washable is the scented entry: 36 chisel-tip markers at $21.67, rated 4.8 across 2,830 ratings, which is $0.60 a pen. It is the dearest set in that table by total price and mid-range per pen. The chisel nib is worth noting, because it is built for broad strokes and poster work rather than for colouring inside a printed line. Alongside it, Crayola's Super Tips 100-count at $19.04 and Ultra Clean 40-count at $14.99 are unscented and carry far more ratings, at 43,050 and 31,918.

Across the corpus, 14 scented products carry buyer-topic data, split between Mr. Sketch and Crayola's Silly Scents range.

What buyers reported

Scent is the topic worth reading, and it is unusually cheerful: 1,382 mentions across the scented range, 492 negative, a 36% rate. "They also smell great (purple/grape is my favorite). I like the chisel tip of these, makes my writing appear neater," wrote one buyer of a 12-count Mr. Sketch set. Enjoyment, a separate topic on the same products, runs to 1,560 mentions with only 20 negative.

The dissent is not about the smell being unpleasant. It is about the smell not being there. "For the price I paid with 50ct its worth it. There is no scents but I don't mind, cause I didn't buy for the scents but for the color choices," wrote one buyer of a Crayola set. Against that, another reported a set still working after two years: "Bought this brand 2 years ago and they still smell and work great."

The failure to plan for is the same one that afflicts every washable marker: caps. Drying time draws 872 reports across 14 washable products, 628 of them negative, a 72% rate, and a separate drying-out topic 314 at the same rate.

Why scent sells this category

Scented markers are bought for classrooms and for children, and the reports say so directly. "I love these- great quality and smells. My students love them. I use them to put happy faces on their papers for immediate feedback while they work," wrote one teacher. That is a use case where the pen is a reward rather than a tool, and it explains why colour count and scent range matter more in this category than nib precision does.

It also explains the nostalgia traffic. Scented markers 90s carries 200 searches a month and mr sketch scented markers commercial 150, up 864% year on year. Those are not purchase queries, and this page will not pretend otherwise.

Scent and toxicity are separate questions

A fragrance claim says nothing about ingredients, and a non-toxic claim says nothing about smell. 450 searches a month ask whether Crayola markers are toxic. Across the catalogue, 122 of the 194 Crayola products carry a non-toxic claim from the manufacturer and 22 name an ACMI or AP certification. Check the pack in front of you, because those claims attach to individual products.

Colour range, and what the counts mean

Scented sets are sold on the number of smells, which is the same marketing move as selling alcohol markers on the number of colours. The counts are broadly honest. Colour selection draws 1,478 reports across 17 washable products at 26% negative, and colour variety 3,080 across 16 at 22%, both low rates for this corpus. What the count does not tell you is nib width, and nib width is the specification that decides whether a pen is usable for the job in hand. A 36-marker chisel-tip set and a 40-marker fine-tip set are not interchangeable, however many fragrances each one carries.

What to buy instead, by job

If the job is a printed colouring page, buy a fine-tip washable set rather than a chisel-tip scented one, because nib width decides whether the pen fits inside a line. If the job is a poster, the chisel is right. If the job is fabric, the conditional cell above applies and a fabric marker is the wash-fast answer at 24,430 searches a month. Scent is a preference layered on top of those decisions, not a substitute for making them.

How this page decides

Counts here are row totals from 17,314 buyer-topic summaries across 4,486 products. Prices are read at build time and go stale. The method is at how we review.

Frequently asked